Game 1: General Alfred M. Gruenther (as Mystery Guest #1 and the panel is blindfolded, Alfred Maximilian Gruenther) - ""Former Supreme Allied Commander in Europe"" and ""President of American National Red Cross"" (salaried; John comments that he is the former NATO commander; John mentions recent floods in West Virginia and states that the Red Cross is attempting to collect a goal of $95 million dollars in charitable donations) Game 2: ""By Golly"" Frager - ""Makes Boxing Gloves"" (self-employed; John does not ask his real first name, and Frager tells Bennett that By Golly is his nickname; from Chicago, IL) Game 3: Fred MacMurray & June Haver (as Mystery Guest Duo) Game 4: Ronald Preston - ""Sewer Inspector"" (salaried; chews gum during his game; from New York, NY) (thetvdb.com)